0 items in Cart
Bay Boy Specialty Sandwiches Logo
  • Order Online
  • 0 items in Cart
  • Order Online
Group Order Tasty Rewards Sign Up For Deals

Bay Boy Specialty Sandwiches Online Ordering Menu

4706 Holly St
Kansas City, MO 64112
(816) 673-3960
11:00 AM - 8:30 PM
98% of 812 customers recommended
Start your carryout or delivery order.
Check Availability

Seasonal Specialty Sandwiches

Specialty sandwiches that are on rotation. Check back often, for it changes fairly regularly.
Pastrami "Reuben" 
Similar to our Nebraskan sandwich, but with premium thin sliced beef pastrami. Has 1001 island dressing, melty swiss cheese and our house Navarre style kraut.
$11.00+
Peaches & Scream 
Turkey, Fontina, Food Life Joy Microgreens, Peach Jam, Candied Jalapeño, on a Spicy Butter Dutch Crunch Roll
$14.00+

Hot Sandwiches

Our specialty selection of hot, toasted and melty sandwiches. Want to build your own hot sandwich? The "Build Your Own" section will be under "Cold Sandwiches" and you can select "Hot/Toasted" there.
Cheese Melt 
It is hot cheese and bread. good bread and good cheese.
$7.00+
Goldilox 
Cold smoked salmon and a Hot bun toasted with the Infused ghee, then there's a capered cream cheese spread, red onions, cucumbers. The bun and the fish and the 'cumber all make a pretty perfectly temperatured sandwich
$15.00+
Hot Pastrami 
Boars head Pastrami and Swiss, pickle, Hot Horseradish sauce and Brown mustard on a buttered and toasted bun is a choice meat and cheese selection.
$12.00+
Nebraskan 
It's Like a Rueben, Like, eerily similar, like so similar we should have called it a Rueben, It's got KC's own Boyles Corned beef, We do a house Bavarian Style Kraut (Hint: it's sweeter and less krauty than other krauts you've met), Swiss cheese. Oh, and we went looking for the 1000 Island for it, got lost ended at the 1001 island, called it a day. Also, some attribute the Rueben sandwiches creation to Omaha Nebraska or one of the outlying areas, we are too by calling it the Nebraskan. If you find this offensive please feel free to include your Complaints with your order, Thank You!
$11.00+
The Bandit 
So Roasted Beef and Smoky cheddar with red onions, but what if for the sauces its like Horseradish and Locally sourced seedless red raspberry jam? I'll tell you what if! It's good, that's the what if.
$13.00+
Jackfruit Jefe (Veggie Version) 
Our vegetarian Jefe, our Mojo'd Jackfruit and mushrooms with swiss, pickle, mustard and Tangy Pepper sauce.
$11.00+

Cold Sandwiches

Our Specialty selection on cold sandwiches. The "Build Your Own" section is in here.
Bay Boy 
Genoa salami, mayo, mustard, our Homemade Garlic sauce, our Original Hot Pepper sauce, lettuce, tomato, red onion, pickle, and your choice of cheese.
$12.00+
Build-a-Wich 
Build your own sandwich, we will make it! Some* Ingredients are subject to availability. *All
$8.00+
The Gobbler 
Our Pitch 2021 Best Sandwich in KC Sandwich, House Chipotle Mayo, Smoked Turkey, Swiss cheese, Red Bell Peppers roasted under the Flames of Success, and Crispity Lettuce to entice a little gobble.
$11.00+
Veggie 
Our Veggie Sammie comes with mayo, mustard, Homemade Garlic Sauce, our Original Hot Pepper sauce, cucumber slices, sautéed mushrooms, lettuce, tomato, red onion, pickles, and provolone cheese.
$10.00+

Lil somethin for the Kids

As the title says, just a lil' somethin' for the kids. R.I.P. Auntie Fee
Ham & cheese 
A half order of meat and choice of cheese on a fresh roll, optional sauce
$6.00+
Peanut Butter & Jelly 
$7.00+

Our Bread

Our Signature Dutch Crunch Bread
Dutch Crunch Roll 
$0.50+

Extras

Side Sauces and Chips
+ Side 
$0.25+
Chips 
Your choice of chips
$2.00+
Extra Sauce on Side 
$0.50

Cloudy Day Cookies

Baked fresh everyday in house, dough made in house by Cloudy Day Cookies. Follow them on instagram @cloudydaycookies
Cloudy Day Cookie 
Cloudy Day Homemade Cookie
$2.50

Drinks

Soda, Tea, and Water
Bottle Water 
$1.00
Glass Bottle Soda 
$2.00+
Your cart is empty.
Accepts Google Pay
Accepts Venmo


  • Visit our Facebook Visit our Instagram Visit our Twitter Visit our Yelp
Powered by Menufy © 2023
  • Accessibility
  • Terms
  • Help
  • Privacy
Loading, please wait.